SONGWRITER DEALS: Part II, By Donald S. Passman
Songwriter101.com is pleased to be able to offer excerpts from Donald S. Passman’s “All You Need To Know About The Music Business,” widely acknowledged as a “must read” for anyone thinking about starting a career in the music business.
As we discussed on page 220, the performing rights societies pay songwriters directly (that is, they don’t pay the publisher, who in turn accounts to the writer). In fact, the societies are so protective of a writer being paid directly that they won’t honor an assignment of performance royalties by the writer. In other words, if the writer tries to sell his or her performance monies, the society will simply refuse to pay the buyer and continue paying the writer. (There is an exception for assignments of performance monies to a publisher who has paid the writer an advance, and for assignments to a bank securing a loan, but these assignments are limited to the amount of the advance or loan.)
Because the writer is paid directly, all songwriter contracts say the writer doesn’t share in any performance monies received by the publisher. Without this language, the writer would get all of the writer’s share (from the society), and a part of the publisher’s share as well. It’s a good idea, however, to provide that, if a society no longer pays writers directly, the publisher must share its receipts. And try to get the publisher to agree not to cross collateralize these monies with advances under your deal, on the theory that the publisher never expected to have performance monies for recoupment in the first place.
PRINTED MUSIC ROYALTIES
As we discussed on page 223, printed music consists primarily of single song sheet music and multi song folio books.
Structure of Business
There are only three major manufacturers of secular printed music in the United States these days, namely Warner/Chappell, Hal Leonard, and Music Sales. This means that, unless your publisher is one of these companies, it will be licensing print rights to one of them. Thus, in songwriter deals with publishers who license out these rights to a printer, it would be eminently logical for the writer to get 50% of the publisher’s IIcensing receipts. Logic, however, has never been a major impediment to the music business, and for some twisted historical reason (guess who it favors), print music royalties are expressed as either a percentage of the retail or wholesale price (on folios), or in pennies (for sheet music).
When we get to single song sheet music, we really enter the Twilight Zone. For at least the past thirty years, sheet music royalties have hovered in the range of 7 per copy. Occasionally some superstars get as high as IN to 12$, and the publishers act as if this is removing their eyeteeth. If you recall from our earlier discussion, however (on page 223), the publisher gets 20% of the marked retail price, which today is about 80.
Why the songwriter still gets such a small amount of the sheet music pie bewilders me. I’ve been told by major publishers it’s because they have favored nations (meaning a contract that says its rate goes up if anyone ever gets more) with a number of old writers, and that raising the pennies for the new guys would cost them a fortune on the older deals. (Favored nations clauses can be in any kind of agreement, not just publishing.) But whatever the reason, this practice is soundly entrenched in the business. There is some comfort in the fact that sheet music doesn’t represent a significant amount of money anymore, so it’s tough to get too excited about it in absolute dollar terms. Still, it’s a rip off.
With regard to folios, remember the printer pays the publisher from 10% to 12.5% of the marked retail price (see page 223). Most songwriter agreements pay the writer 10% of wholesale (you can kick it up to 12.5% with a bit of clout), which approximates 50% of the publisher’s receipts. However, to my knowledge, none of the major print houses accounts to publishers on the basis of wholesale, so most publishers merely split their income and call it good. 1emember to allow pro ration only on the basis of copyrighted, royalty bearing songs (see page 224).
Name and Likeness
In addition to the writer’s portion, if you ask, most publishers will give you 5% of wholesale for use of your name and likeness in a personality folio (see page 223), which is about half of the publisher’s receipts. You can often hold out for the full 5% of retail that the publisher gets, arguing this payment is for your name and likeness, and the publisher shouldn’t share in it.
Charges Against Royalties
Often a publisher pays the costs to create a demo of your song or, in some deals, pays you $600 or so for each demo you make on your own. A demo is an informal recording made solely for the purposes of pitching a song to artists (similar to those for record deals, discussed on page 101). It’s usually made by an unknown singer (or the songwriter), accompanied by one or two instruments (which, since the advent of synthesizers, can sound like the London Symphony Orchestra). The publishers try to charge 50% to 100% of the demo charges against the writer, and as your bargaining power increases, this amount decreases to as low as zero.
No songwriting agreement should charge you for anything other than the following: (1) demos; (2) collection costs (that means (a) monies spent by the publisher to collect your song’s earnings, such as Harry Fox fees [see page 208]; and (b) the cost of chasing deadbeats who don’t pay); and (3) subpublishing fees (see page 229).
All other costs of administration, copyrighting, advertising, etc., should be borne by the publisher. This is their cost of doing business and the reason they get 50% of the income. (When you share in publishing, you’re charged with much more. We’ll get to that on page 263.)
Publishers typically account and pay within sixty to ninety days after the close of each calendar semiannual period (June 30 and December 31). Some superstar songwriters get quarterly accountings, but this is rare. A quarterly accounting comes after each calendar quarter, meaning March 31, June 30, September 30, and December 31. The advantage, of course, is that you get your money earlier.
Contracts typically limit the period in which you can object to your accounting statements, and most first drafts say you have to object within one year or you lose your right to do so. You can usually get this extended to at least two years, and often three. Beyond that is rare.
Posted Nov 01, 2004
Very Interesting Article. There is so much to know! It seems like there are a lot of ways for an up and coming writer to get taken advantage of if he/she isn’t careful. Thanks for posting this.
Lincoln, NE USA
Glad you enjoyed. All this and much more in his print book-
Hello my fellow dreamers! This is an excellant article and those who do not understand much about the business need as much wisdom as can be given. I like how Mr. Passman was real with his words kind of like a friend was talking to you. Everybody knows it’s good to have a friend who knows the business. Remember guys know what you want before you go get it. Negaotiation on a contract will get you a better deal.If we show publishers we have an understanding about the biz and know what we want in our contracts we will get a better deal.All those who lack the knowledge buy this book.It WILL help.
Stay cool guys and Rock on
It’s great advice, but I also want to know how to get my music heard and distributed.